Wednesday, 27 July 2011

"Mum, I would HATE to be gay."


My nine-year old son was sitting at the table one day, looked up at me and said completely out of the blue, "Mum, I would HATE to be gay."

I was furious. I sat down with him, ready for a long discussion about equal rights and injustice and tolerance and ignorance. No child of mine was going to be homophobic goddamit. I don't know if it's right or wrong to enforce your own personal beliefs on to your children. I try to let them have their own views, give them space to make up their own assumptions about things.

But I was not letting him get up from that table until he got a crash course in respect and kindness. Until I had full assurance that he was not growing up homophobic. No kid of mine is going to be a homophobe. GODDAMIT.

Calmly, but with my head racing, I asked him why he said that. Was it because his dad and older brother are such macho manly men? Did he see something on TV? Goddamit.

He stopped his drawing, looked at me and said, "Well, because, if I was gay .... I would have to hide it."

My heart. Oh.

We sat there for a while in silence. Wrapping my head around the fact that not only was my son not being homophobic at all, he was coming from a place of empathy. He already knows that to be gay would be problematic. I thought of all of the children in his school ... there would be a percentage of them that ARE gay. And know that they are gay, and they would feel ashamed. Struggling to hide their Truth.

That's just so bloody sad.

I love gay people - specifically "out" gay people. I think it's because, they have struggled a lot to get where they are. People who go through struggles in their life, are often remarkable. They know themselves. They're battle-weary. They're deeper.

I told Max that yes, it would be hard to be gay, wouldn't it? But if he ever finds out that somebody is gay, to understand and never tease or judge them. He looked at me like I was an idiot. "Pfft! Of course I wouldn't do that, mum!"

And then I thought some more. "And, sweetheart ... if you were to ever tell me that you were gay? I would not care one bit. I love you so much, and ..."

"MUM. I'm not gay, I was just telling you something."

"Ok mate."

"Mum?"

"Yes mate?"

"Imagine if Rocco was gay! He would be the toughest gay guy in the world."

And we both laughed, because Rocco WOULD be the toughest gay guy around. Totes butch.

If any of my sons were gay, I would wave the rainbow flag from the highest rafter. I would beg to be in their float at mardis gras, I would hold dinner parties for all of their friends, and I would embrace them all with my whole heart. I would want to walk them down the aisle at their wedding. I would want them to be allowed to have a wedding.

::

This is my favourite "It gets better" video, from the wonder people at Pixar. The guy at 5 minutes and 35 seconds? Oh my god. I wonder how his mum reacted when he came out. I hope she loved him as fiercely as the love I felt for him when I first watched this.



I know some brillant bloggers, who happen to be gay. I adore Rick from the Ambiguity Report, Maybe. I'll be spending some time with St Murphy this weekend and I can't WAIT.

I think most of all, if one of my kids came home and told me he was gay, I would feel instant sorrow. For the stupid straight world is hard to live in ... they'd be facing a lot of real-live ignorance and hate from stupid people. Life's hard enough, man.

61 comments:

  1. My Dad used to be extremely homophobic. He was actively encouraged to be that way by his father.

    Age has softened him though, and having a grandchild has melted him.
    Map Guy and I said to him, in passing, that there was nothing Tricky could do that would upset him other than being Gay.

    My Dad became immediately defensive, picked up Tricky and said "I don't care what you are, my little guy, I'll love you no matter what".

    My heart soared. He gets it now, after all these years.

    I doubt he's ready to hear about his not-so-straight daughter yet though! All in good time.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This post is why you DO ROCK! Awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Homophobes shit me. I do not care who you are sexually attracted to. It is none of my business. My kids are growing up in a very very gay friendly household, as did I. It is a wonderful thing x

    ReplyDelete
  4. Gorgeous post and gorgeous video!

    ReplyDelete
  5. My kids watch a show called Dance Academy on ABC and one of the story lines was one of the teenage boys had a crush on another teenage boy but he was conflicted by it because he was sure he wasn't gay. The scriptwriters explored this and made it all positive.

    My kids were unsure why it was even a talking point; as my daughter put it, "It's just natural to like someone". So far my kids haven't been clued into just how nasty society can be about homosexual relationships.

    Because like you, if one of my kids are gay and they don't say anything and feel horrible all by themselves then I haven't done my job.

    Love & stuff
    Mrs M

    ReplyDelete
  6. So beautifully written and I ADORE your son.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Tears- even before I got to the clip.

    Fucking brilliant blog. And I save my swear words up for really important occasions. xxxx

    ReplyDelete
  8. What a great conversation with your son! I think it's the times that we just talk normally about sexuality that are changing perceptions.

    The video was amazing. Yes, to that beautiful man who just wants to go home to his partner. sob.

    My daughter first told me she liked girls when she was 11 and will openly tell most people (if it comes up, at 13), that she is gay. I told her there is nothing she can do to stop me from loving her and thinking she is an amazing creation.

    We will face discrimination head on when, and if, it happens. I will advocate for her if she needs me to but mostly, I will give her the confidence and support she needs to do it for herself.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Once again Eden you leave me speechless. I can not tell you how amazing I think this post is and for so many reasons. As you know it's a matter very close to my heart and your words, actions and feelings are truly inspiring. People like you make the world a far better place.

    And your two sons are incredibly blessed to have a beautiful mum like you.

    So much love, xoxoxoxo
    St. Murphy

    ReplyDelete
  10. <3! your son is just too awesome for words.

    ReplyDelete
  11. what a great post! I often worry that my husband would freak out if we had a gay son. I would not care one iota other than to feel pain for them on their struggle. I love gay people, for all the reasons you listed.

    ReplyDelete
  12. My kids know everyone is different, and that's okay. If they were gay I would be totally fine with it, just as if they were straight, single, or anything else. All you want is for your kids to be happy. Thank God society is not as discriminatory as it used to be, and hopefully, less people are being bullied, beaten or ashamed of their sexuality. One of my friends told me she was only sad when her son came out, because she knew he'd never be able to marry and have kids. Well now he can have kids ... let's hope that he can get married one day too.

    ReplyDelete
  13. don't ever feel 'sorry' for us, for that only continues to say that we have some 'inferiority' that makes us somehow 'less human'. Empathy with the struggles against peoples fear is much more necessary. In fact, if more straight people actually stood up against all forms of sexual and gender orientation discrimination, and paved the way for other straight people to lose their fear and prejudices, we would all live in a much happier world. The funny thing is, that so very often gay and lesbian people know that we live in a better world, one filled with love and acceptance, and the ability to live freely outside others expectations and 'rule book'. I have never felt freer and more empowered as I do as a lesbian, and I feel so much empathy for the world of limitations, expectations, and fear of almost everything that 'straight' people live in...

    We appreciate your support, but know that we are 'all' in this together..

    ReplyDelete
  14. Pep, thank you for your comment. I don't feel "sorry" for you, I really apologise if it came across that way.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Oh Eden. I am forwarding this to a an eleven year old boy who needs to read this and watch this clip.

    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  16. What a beautiful boy you have there. You have obviously done an amazing job with him.

    I hope that there are plenty more like him (and you) in the world. x

    ReplyDelete
  17. PS Andrew (lovely husband) just read this. He is fairly passionate about gay rights. He told me to tell you that you and your boys are all in the right space.

    He also said "I just hope our kids find love and good sex. Regardless of gender." This echoes my feelings entirely.

    I hope and pray our children find all this stuff becomes easier & easier as they grown up.

    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  18. Meh - I knew that's where Max was going. He's got an empathetic side to him. And with you to offset his supermacho male role models, he'll be just fine.

    My daughter can be anything she wants to be.

    ReplyDelete
  19. That's a beautiful son you're raising there, Eden. Has to come from somewhere. He's learning about love and respect and tolerance and acceptance from you.

    I've 'known' you and your blog for only a matter of weeks, and I can already see it, what an amazing mother you must be, what an amazing friend you'd be to have. Your boys are lucky to have you. And all of Rocco's butch gay mates will be too. :D

    ReplyDelete
  20. This is the first blog I have ever read of yours, and followed from Chickchat purely because of the title.

    I grew up in a very gay-friendly household, and so will my children. And I so agree with what Lucy and husband said "I just hope our kids find love and good sex. Regardless of gender."

    People should not be made to feel bad because of who they are attracted to, or who they fall in love with. I know a woman who will openly admit that she is more attracted to men, but her soul mate just happens to be a woman. They have been together longer than my husband and I.

    I hate that even after all these years, there is loneliness and fear attatched to being gay, that there is so much stigma attached to it. Being gay isn't any more 'bad' than being straight is.

    There is enough hate in the world.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Wow wipe eyes, warm feeling in heart ,shaking my head in amazement and picture of St Murphy in my mind wow he is lucky!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Amazing! What a great post. Your son is a visionary of how people today should be--understanding of what it is that gay people go through. You're a great mom!

    ReplyDelete
  23. My stepson was 10 when he said it sucked that my gay friends couldn't get married in Oz. He said people should have the right to marry the person they love. He's awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Well damn Edenland, that made me smudge my water-proof mascara! I don't even know what to say, except
    I agree with everything you've said. xxxxx

    ReplyDelete
  25. OMG, I totally love your kids. My son Joey made me so proud when he pronounced that is was stupid that gay people couldn't marry.

    And, Eden, if any of my boys ended up being gay, I'd be right there flying the rainbow flag with you.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Love the post and the video. xxx

    ReplyDelete
  27. Love this post!! Go you for raising your boys so beautifuly!!
    My little brother is gay & so help me if anyone dosent support him i would draw blood , just saying ;) lol
    I am so proud of my brother & i cant wait to have this conversation with my boys to show them being gay is perfectly ok and to be proud of their uncle too
    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  28. Wonderful post.

    My Uncle used to tell his kids, and me and my siblings, if we were gay, he would disown us. I remember hearing that and knowing, even though I was very young, that it was offensive and wrong.

    Thanks for that video, it was really special and powerful.

    xx

    ReplyDelete
  29. I love this.
    It's a concern for us too. Not that we are seeing any prejudice yet at 5 and 2, but just that I know that it will come eventually. I think it's natural for kids to mention things, likes and dislikes and all of that. It doesn't make them bad people. It just gives us a chance to teach them that being straight or gay is something like a skin colour or gender or even hair colour. It's a wonderful thing because it makes us all that little bit more unique.

    We get told our eldest will "be gay" all the time. I roll my eyes. He's 5, like he gives a shit about sex or sexual orientation. And if he is gay? So be it! It doesn't change my love for him, or my opinion of him. But I do find that the prejudice comes mostly from grown males. I don't get why but that's just what I see.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Thanks for sharing this. I float into your blog once in a while but just had to say how much this moved me. I sobbed uncontrollably at 5 mins 35 secs.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Your awesomeness gene has been passed on to your kids, Eden. I love hearing your interactions with them. Love Max's observation about Rocco! It just shows his absolute acceptance of all people and things - something you've taught him!

    ReplyDelete
  32. If my children can find love and happiness in this life, Well, that is the only thing that matters, all people are children of this earth and have the right to love who ever they please. Thanks again Eden for speaking up on an issue that most people are a little to scared to talk about. My son and your son and the sons of others who have written in here will know to care for others no matter who they chose to share their life with, because we are raising them to actually care.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Wow. Look at all these juicy, beautiful comments. It looks like I am not the only parent who thinks like this. Of course I knew that anyway ... but Rex you just nailed it. People are a bit hesitant to talk about it. I felt a bit odd writing it out, like, am I even allowed to say this?

    Of course I am. It was a beautifully innocent conversation, which I'm so glad to have shared here.

    ReplyDelete
  34. I talked to a colleague once about TLG's obsession with cars, and he said "at least you know your son is not gay" like it's a complement. I was shocked into silence. This is a highly educated, highly intelligent guy. Well maybe not that intelligent. Unfortunately this kind of thinking is still prevalent in our society. Heck, my parents have sympathies for the parents in "Wedding Banquet"...

    Brilliant post as usual Eden.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Great post.

    I just don't understand why people are so anti about this issue.

    Like a previous commenter said what someone else does in their bedroom (laundry, couch et al) is their own business.

    It's ironic really that they hate the love.

    ReplyDelete
  36. People who are homophobic or who harbor hate for any different individuals are TAUGHT that...so no worries on your part. It sounds like you teach your children to respect others of all kinds ;) If only everyone in the worlds could be taught to respect differences.

    ReplyDelete
  37. I love your boy and this post. Homophobia really p's me off!

    ReplyDelete
  38. What an amazing piece of writing and a wonderful conversation with Max.

    I agree, if either of my children came to me and told me they were gay I would fee sorrow . . . not because they are gay but because the world continues to be such a harsh place for someone who is deemed different.

    Gay, straight . . . none of that matters to me. What matters is the person. Are they a good person? Do they treat others with respsect and empathy? Do they give their love unconditionally? These are the things that matter.
    Jenn

    ReplyDelete
  39. I don't generally comment on your blog, although I read it.
    I absolutely love this passage. Very much. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Eden, I'm only getting to this post now. AMAZING! Amazing you; amazing son. x

    ReplyDelete
  41. I have already had these kind conversations with my 3 and a half y/o. While we do not personally know any gay parents, I know that soon enough it will happen, the "mommy, why does Suzy have two daddies?" She has told me many times that she wants to marry a girl. I asked why she wouldn't want to marry daddy? She replied "Ewww cause he's a boy".
    I am with you, if she indeed is gay (which at this point I am not sure) I would absolutely have NO problem with it. I cant stand people that are mean to others that are considered difft. I have always stood up for the under dog since I was a child, and I want my daughter to do the same. So I have told her that some kids have 2 moms, or 2 dads, or just a mom and no dad, etc. And that it is okay to love anyone you want to. So she already has it in her head that this is just how it is. And when she is old enough and asks me, I will be completely honest and reassure her that she can tell me anything (other than she murdered someone) and I will still love her more than the sun, moon and stars. Your son is a wise young man!! I can only hope that my daughter will be as open minded and kind. Lisa

    ReplyDelete
  42. The one song I suggest for homophobes: Lily Allen's "Fuck you". Such a sweet little diddy :)

    ReplyDelete
  43. What a brilliant conversation to have with your son...

    well done you! Hope you are having a proud mumma moment. I would be. :)

    ReplyDelete
  44. Good lord, you are raising ONE HELL of a kid.

    ReplyDelete
  45. I was crying through most of the clip and I just have to say to you that your son is an amazing human being.

    ReplyDelete
  46. Great post! As a teacher, I frequently see homophobic behaviour in schools, and as a PDHPE teacher in particular I always teach students about preventing discrimination and bullying. A persons sexual preference does not change who they are as a person.
    I currently work at a performing arts high school and the attitudes there are very different to other schools I have worked in. The kids are open about their sexuality, and are not discriminated against by other students and I'd like to say not by teachers either, although I know sometimes some students creativity in fashion/dress sense on mufti days has been frowned upon, although I can't really tell if this is discrimination as much as trying to prevent them being singled out like anyone wearing skirts that are too short, or tops that are too revealing. Anyway, I just think it's a nice change to teach in a school that is so different in terms of its beliefs, opinions and values. It makes for a fantastic variety of discussions in class and no opinion is left unexplored. It's a great feeling within the student body too, to see students not afraid to really be who they are at any age.

    ReplyDelete
  47. I love this post. What insight your little man had at such a young age. Kuddos to you for teaching him such accpetance.

    ReplyDelete
  48. I grew up, and still live in, a very Christian, conservative area, People are wigged out by the fact that I'm a Buddhist. I felt so terrible that a couple guy friends growing up had to squelch themselves so much to avoid being tortured and beat up and ostracized. I have no problem telling anyone that whoever my children turn out to be orientation-wise is how my body made them, and that is fine by me. And if someone targets my child for being gay, it is the dickweed that will make me furious, not my child's orientation.

    ReplyDelete
  49. I can't tell you how much this meant to me! This past weekend my sixteen year old told me he's gay. We've always had an open discussion about things and I am grateful he trusted me with this. He is relieved and a little scared, as am I, but only because it is the "unknown" for me! The video made me cry - I truly needed that today! There are no coincidences!!!

    ReplyDelete
  50. I just love the way you think! Its like you are inside my head.

    ReplyDelete
  51. If my son were gay, I'd finally get someone in my family to go shopping with me and not complain.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Totally agree with every word. x

    ReplyDelete
  53. Very cool, Eden. I totally get that first reaction you had. I get jumpy like that when I hear something about skin color or body size come out of kids' mouths. I tell them there are other ways to describe people.

    I think you're a good Mum.

    ReplyDelete
  54. I knew my son was gay, always. Not because he was particularly effeminite, but because I just knew.
    When he eventually told me, at 16, he did it by telling me "Mum, I have met someone, his name is..." I played it super calm, cool and collected and we chatted about his new boyfriend and what he was like. It was lovely. I did not want to make an issue of the fact he had just confirmed to me that he was gay, because I couldn't care less. I just wanted to celebrate with him the fact he had found someone to give his heart to.
    When he went to bed that night, I did let my inner "Edina" come out...I excitedly rang my best friends to tell them the news. I was so happy.
    We have always had close gay friends and our kids never thought anything of it. They just believe you love who you love.
    My son and some of his friends were set upon one night by idiot homophobes and were lucky to escape only with a few bruises. The police did catch the culprits, but nothing ever came of it. How despicable is that?
    I despise the fact he does not have the same rights as me or his two sisters.

    ReplyDelete
  55. This is such a fantastic post! I love your blog (thanks to Carly Findlay's blog for directing me here).

    I have several gay friends, all with varying comfort within their own gay skins. I wish they could accept themselves and then perhaps the rest of the world may not be so afraid. Or that I could kick each homophobe in the shins, one by one. Ah, but I guess they're the ones missing out! It's just really sad.

    Your son sounds like the coolest little guy! If only every child was being raised in such an open, loving environment!

    ReplyDelete
  56. It's bizarre to think that we haven't come further in the last 15 years. Didn't it feel like we were just around the corner and here we are now still listening to people debate things like marriage equality that are simply self-evident to the rest of us?

    ReplyDelete
  57. What a fabulous video. And I love what Max said. What a wise child.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Eden,
    I have not been by to read your blog for a few weeks now, simply because your words hit me so close to home and oftentimes tear my heart right open with how you hit the heart of things. And I have been somewhat vulnerable and overly emo lately, and just felt I couldn't take it!

    But I came by tonight and am catching up on what I have missed out on, and reading these particular words, well, I think I'm a little bit more in love with you every day.

    It gives me hope that my children will grow up in a world where homophobes are the ones who are looked down on and face derision, rather than us homos.

    Keep on keeping on babe, you are the truest voice I know.

    ReplyDelete
  59. In 1981 as a 15 year old terrified boy. I tried to commit suicide.

    Thirty years later life has brought me much heartbreak. But joy and adventure and happiness too.

    But today, at 45 I have a wonderful partner with whom I raise two wonderful children. we have the blessing of so many good friends and family who congratulated us warmly when we decided to enter into a Civil Partnership here in the UK.

    It got better.

    ReplyDelete
  60. In 1981 as a 15 year old terrified boy. I tried to commit suicide.

    Thirty years later life has brought me much heartbreak. But joy and adventure and happiness too.

    But today, at 45 I have a wonderful partner with whom I raise two wonderful children. we have the blessing of so many good friends and family who congratulated us warmly when we decided to enter into a Civil Partnership here in the UK.

    It got better.

    ReplyDelete

Write to be understood, speak to be heard. - Lawrence Powell

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...